.png)
The Bakery
Always Made Fresh Daily
At Farmwald’s, everything is baked the old-fashioned way. No shortcuts and no artificial junk — just real ingredients, handcrafted recipes, and the kind of flavor that only Amish baking can deliver. All our goods are made fresh each morning, and many sell out fast. If you’d like to order pies, sourdough, or large batches of baked goods, we always recommend calling ahead so we can have your order ready for you.
Call ahead to reserve fresh pies, cakes, donuts, or any of our baked goods, especially during the holidays or when ordering for large groups.
Fresh Pretzel Bar
Stop by our Pretzel Bar and enjoy warm, soft pretzels made fresh every day. Each pretzel is hand-shaped, baked to perfection, and served hot for the best flavor and texture. Whether you like yours classic, buttery, or paired with one of our delicious dipping options, our fresh pretzels make the perfect snack anytime you visit.
Cookies and Whoopie Pies
Treat yourself to some of our best bakery favorites. Our cookies are baked fresh and packed with homemade flavor in every bite. Our classic Amish whoopie pies are soft, sweet, and filled with creamy goodness that keeps customers coming back for more. And don’t forget our fresh-baked banana bread, made the old-fashioned way with real ingredients and that warm, comforting flavor everyone loves. Whether you’re grabbing a quick snack or taking home something sweet for the family, this section of our bakery delivers pure homemade goodness every time.
Homemade Pies
We make every kind of pie you can imagine — fruit pies, cream pies, specialty pies, and more. The crusts are flaky, the fillings are rich, and every pie is made the traditional Amish way. Whether you need a single pie or a large order for a gathering, just call ahead and we’ll have it fresh for you.
Sourdough Bread
We bake three types of fresh sourdough bread each week:
• Jalapeño Cheese — a spicy, cheesy loaf packed with flavor
• Pepperoni Cheese — savory, hearty, and perfect for sandwiches
• Traditional Sourdough — simple, rustic, and great with any meal
Each loaf is fermented and baked the Amish way, with no preservatives and no additive
Cheesecakes
Our cheesecakes are rich, creamy, and made completely from scratch using simple, high-quality ingredients. Each one is baked low and slow for the perfect texture, then finished with classic toppings and seasonal flavors. Whether you want a whole cheesecake for a gathering or individual slices to enjoy, our bakery has fresh options available throughout the week. Call ahead if you need multiple cheesecakes or a special flavor for an event.
